Open the Gates of Justice (in Albany)

At 6:00 am this morning, Ariella Rosen, our Rabbinic Intern, and I boarded a bus together with thirty interfaith clergy bound for Albany.  The Rockland Clergy for Social Justice fulfilled our pledge to call on Governor Cuomo and legislative leaders to initiate immediate fiscal and administrative oversight in the East Ramapo Central School District and to revise the structure, governance and financing of that school district.  On the two hour ride up the Thruway we were briefed about our mission and the many advocacy meetings that we would have.  Just after a stop for coffee, I davenned the prayers of Rosh Hodesh, the New Month.  When I reached Hallel, I sang softly to myself: Pitchu li sha’arei tzedek – Open for me the Gates of Justice.  “How perfect,” I thought to myself, “the Jewish calendar can be so in sync with the world.Image

The day was a big success. I will be sharing information with everyone about the ways in which each one of us can become involved in this issue that is of concern to so many of our congregants in the days ahead.  Today we met with Larry Schwartz, Secretary to Governor Cuomo, Speaker Sheldon Silver, Senate leaders Dean Skelos, Jeffrey Klein and John Flanagan, and Senator Andrea Stewart-Cousins. Throughout the day we were accompanied by Senator David Carlucci, Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffe and Assemblyman Kenneth Zebrowski; all three are champions of our cause and deserve our thanks. 


For tonight, I would like to share with you the words that I spoke at the Prayer Vigil/Press Conference, to give you a sense of the impact felt in Albany when a unified band of rabbis, ministers, pastors and imams raised our voices together for justice.

I am proud to stand before you this afternoon representing the Orangetown Jewish Center, a congregation of more than 500 families who are concerned about the issue of fair and meaningful access to education for all young people in our county.  

On the Jewish calendar, today is Rosh Hodesh, the first day of a new month. It is appropriate to be here today because Rosh Hodesh is a day of introspection and renewal. It is a day of optimism. Interestingly, it is also a day set apart for women and today as the sole woman clergy in attendance, I raise my voice for all of the mothers who send their children to school in the East Ramapo Central School District and for the teachers in that school district, the vast majority of whom are women.

Rosh Hodesh is a day of witnessing. In history, a new month was not declared until witnesses saw a new moon in the sky.  Now this witnessing was by necessity subtle because what was being seen in the sky was actually the absence of the moon. Today, we stand before you as witnesses to important things that are absent from the lives of the families in the East Ramapo Central School District.  Absent is protection for the children. Absent is fair governance of their schools. Absent is the education that is the Constitutional right of every child in the State of New York.

I stand today as a witness.

Consider the student in Spring Valley High School who has no Child Psychology and Day Care class to take because it was eliminated from the budget. Her dream to begin a career in Day Care will not be fulfilled. I am a witness to her dream.

Consider the student in Ramapo High School whose dream of a college scholarship in swimming or wrestling or tennis is crushed because those teams were eliminated from the budget. I am a witness to his dream.

Consider the mother sending her children to school each day who has sidelined her dreams of their succeeding in a competitive world thanks to education. Now she is more concerned that they return from school safely each day. Security guards were eliminated form the budget. I am a witness to her dreams for her children.

Consider the father who is a mathematician or a musician or … fill in the blank.  Like any father, he had dreams of his children’s following in his footsteps.  But there are no math electives, not even Advanced Algebra. There are no music programs at all in the Elementary Schools and the award winning marching band no longer exists.  All were cut from the budget. I am a witness to his dreams.

Consider the guidance counselor in the high school or the sports coaches in the middle schools or the kindergarten teaching assistant. They were committed to careers in education but their jobs were eliminated. I am a witness to their dreams.

All that I witness leads me to the only possible response: a cry for justice. Here in Albany, I pray that you hear the same call. We clergy of every faith have gathered together as witnesses. We represent our congregations who stand as witnesses. We cannot and will not look away.  You are our elected officials. We pray that you join us as witnesses so that we can take action together.

Tags: , , , ,

6 responses to “Open the Gates of Justice (in Albany)”

  1. Ruth Hess says :

    Dear Paula, Your presentation was brilliant! As a former educator, I am so sad for the unfulfilled dreams of the students and their parents.

    I hope the politicians heard your cry for help and respond quickly.

    Fondly, Ruth Hess

    Sent from my iPhone


    • Mimi&Mel Rosenstock says :

      Mimi & Mel Rosenstock.are so proud of you and all who joined you in. Albany. May all the deserving children. In East Ramapo receive the education they are entitled to.

  2. merry1moss says :

    Yasher koach for your very powerful and important message ! XoMiriam

    Sent from my iPhone


  3. Janet Miller says :

    Thank you, thank you–for being a voice for the OJC. I pray your passionate words reach the ears, minds and hearts of those who have the power to make changes to this broken system.

  4. J. Scott Strauss says :

    I personally have experienced injustice caused by unfair tax-funding of our education. This issue is not limited to NYS. When I was going to public schools in Southern California back in the 50s throughout the 60s, I went to poor quality schools and had lousy teachers. Why? I and my siblings lived in a lower-income neighborhood, whereas state funding was very little for the school district I went to. Yes, at that time we had art, music, advanced courses, and sporting and drama activities.But we had no strong leadership and role models. It did not matter that I had a 3.0 GPA. I had to make up a lot through college.

    What happening to NYS, particularly in East Ramapo School District is unfair. I still believe that private schools (religious or otherwise) should NOT be funded by taxpayers’ monies.That was the way of life decades ago and still should be paid by the parents who prefer private schools.Property taxes is a public matter and should be spent on public schools like other public services.

  5. Sally Kagan says :

    So moved by your words, so proud of your voice, so hopeful for the possibility of change…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: